'Evil Dead' review by Captain Raptor
I've been training for this review for a while, it would seem. Over the past months I've watched Evil Dead II and an assortment of other 80's movies, the idea being to give me a better understanding of the culture the film comes from and what it is to be compared to. That seems to have been a waste of time, as the new Evil Dead is an entirely different beast to what I have already seen. The threadbare plot is still the same, and there's a couple of things they've kept in from the original (would it really be an Evil Dead film without a tree-molestation scene or a chainsaw?), but tonally this film is almost unrecognisable.
The thing is, the new Evil Dead is a horror movie and nothing but. Its predecessors blurred the line between what's so horrific it's frightening and what's so horrific it's hilarious; it was a horror-comedy in the truest sense. Fede Alvarez's latest version has no humour to offer up whatsoever, choosing to go the full horror route. It keep some of the original films's successes, like the intense POV shots, although filming it with a high-resolution camera kind of ruins the atmosphere. The cinematography is very crisp, very effective in all other circumstances, however. The other positive similarity is that both films use the savagery of the demons sophisticatedly. A lot of horror films are content to scare the viewer simply by making them jump, whereas Evil Dead has greater ambitions: any fear comes from a sheer sense of dread, as the tormenting demon does increasingly disturbing damage to both its own and its victim's bodies. It veers on becoming torture porn, but it's nice to see a horror movie attempt to mentally scar the audience rather than merely cause them to twitch. The atmosphere of the film is near-perfect: a foreboding pre-credits scene gives you an idea what to expect from our hellish antagonist, and as you watch the teens innocently use various sharp and electrical appliances at the beginning of the film, you can immediately start to see how badly things are going to go.
The obvious element the film is lacking is one Ashley J motherfucking Williams. It would be nice to see more from our wide-eyed, amputated friend, but all things must come to an end. The real error is that a franchise that produced one of cinema's coolest heroes was incapable of producing a single memorable character. I accept for a 90 minute horror film that characterisation isn't exactly a priority, but I left the cinema only remembering one character's name, and there were times when I could not care less about what was going to happen to somebody because they were so bland. The worst of the bunch is Eric, played by Lou Taylor Pucci. He's the irritating one who accidently summons the ancient hellspawn, because somebody has to (although all I could think of were the wise words of The Cabin In The Wood's Marty: "I'm drawing a line in the sand. Do not read the fucking Latin") and he then has the audacity to criticize the other characters for failing to deal with the situation appropriately. The dialogue is awful, and the decision to treat the film with complete seriousness makes it look foolish, both because it's painfully unoriginal and particularly because they could have drawn some excellent black comedy out of mistaking demonic behaviour for heroin withdrawal symptoms, a key part of the plot treated entirely straight-faced. The characters commit the same clichéd acts that all teenagers in horror movies do, which gives the film a feel of repetitiveness and redundancy.
Some interesting set-pieces aside, Evil Dead brings nothing to the table, and it might have been better to let the franchise rest in peace. The characters are infuriating; you might start rooting for the demon because at least it's interesting, and all the gore in the world (the film uses an astonishing 25,000 litres of fake blood) can't compensate for the ensuing boredom when the film starts acting predictably. Evil Dead is a film with some good intentions that falls flat on its feet, but badly made horror is still watchable. In terms of films about mutilating young adults in the woods, it pales in comparison to the original Evil Dead films and The Cabin In The Woods, but there are jaw-dropping moments and the atmosphere that runs through the piece is enthralling enough to at least make it better than Cabin Fever.
The thing is, the new Evil Dead is a horror movie and nothing but. Its predecessors blurred the line between what's so horrific it's frightening and what's so horrific it's hilarious; it was a horror-comedy in the truest sense. Fede Alvarez's latest version has no humour to offer up whatsoever, choosing to go the full horror route. It keep some of the original films's successes, like the intense POV shots, although filming it with a high-resolution camera kind of ruins the atmosphere. The cinematography is very crisp, very effective in all other circumstances, however. The other positive similarity is that both films use the savagery of the demons sophisticatedly. A lot of horror films are content to scare the viewer simply by making them jump, whereas Evil Dead has greater ambitions: any fear comes from a sheer sense of dread, as the tormenting demon does increasingly disturbing damage to both its own and its victim's bodies. It veers on becoming torture porn, but it's nice to see a horror movie attempt to mentally scar the audience rather than merely cause them to twitch. The atmosphere of the film is near-perfect: a foreboding pre-credits scene gives you an idea what to expect from our hellish antagonist, and as you watch the teens innocently use various sharp and electrical appliances at the beginning of the film, you can immediately start to see how badly things are going to go.
The obvious element the film is lacking is one Ashley J motherfucking Williams. It would be nice to see more from our wide-eyed, amputated friend, but all things must come to an end. The real error is that a franchise that produced one of cinema's coolest heroes was incapable of producing a single memorable character. I accept for a 90 minute horror film that characterisation isn't exactly a priority, but I left the cinema only remembering one character's name, and there were times when I could not care less about what was going to happen to somebody because they were so bland. The worst of the bunch is Eric, played by Lou Taylor Pucci. He's the irritating one who accidently summons the ancient hellspawn, because somebody has to (although all I could think of were the wise words of The Cabin In The Wood's Marty: "I'm drawing a line in the sand. Do not read the fucking Latin") and he then has the audacity to criticize the other characters for failing to deal with the situation appropriately. The dialogue is awful, and the decision to treat the film with complete seriousness makes it look foolish, both because it's painfully unoriginal and particularly because they could have drawn some excellent black comedy out of mistaking demonic behaviour for heroin withdrawal symptoms, a key part of the plot treated entirely straight-faced. The characters commit the same clichéd acts that all teenagers in horror movies do, which gives the film a feel of repetitiveness and redundancy.
Some interesting set-pieces aside, Evil Dead brings nothing to the table, and it might have been better to let the franchise rest in peace. The characters are infuriating; you might start rooting for the demon because at least it's interesting, and all the gore in the world (the film uses an astonishing 25,000 litres of fake blood) can't compensate for the ensuing boredom when the film starts acting predictably. Evil Dead is a film with some good intentions that falls flat on its feet, but badly made horror is still watchable. In terms of films about mutilating young adults in the woods, it pales in comparison to the original Evil Dead films and The Cabin In The Woods, but there are jaw-dropping moments and the atmosphere that runs through the piece is enthralling enough to at least make it better than Cabin Fever.